Sir Keir Starmer to submit Labour Israel-Hamas amendment to Commons amid worries over party unity

November 14, 2023

Labour will put forward an amendment to parliament on Wednesday that will give MPs a vote on the Israel-Hamas war, the party has said.

A spokesperson confirmed the move amid concerns some Labour MPs could be tempted to vote for a rival SNP amendment that would expose divisions within the party.

They said the amendment "reaffirms the position" set out by Sir Keir Starmer and reflected the party's concerns regarding the status of Israeli hostages, the "insufficient" amount of aid and utilities entering and being distributed in Gaza, the scale of civilian casualties and the amount of violence on the West Bank.

The spokesman hinted that if the the House of Commons Speaker selects the party's amendment, Labour MPs will be ordered to abstain on the SNP amendment.

"We're not going to be engaging with the party political game-playing by the SNP in parliament," they said.

Labour has been divided over its approach to the conflict, with numerous backbenchers and shadow ministers calling for a ceasefire.

But the leadership has stood by its own calls for so-called humanitarian pauses to allow aid and supplies to get into the Gaza Strip - echoing the position of the government.

Follow live: Number 10 confirms tent crackdown pushed by Braverman shelved

The discord within Labour has been ramped up by the prospect of the SNP amendment being presented to parliament on Wednesday, giving all MPs an opportunity to vote in favour of a ceasefire - if it is selected by the Speaker.

Such a vote could highlight the level of upset on Sir Keir's backbenches, with rumours even shadow ministers could rebel against Labour's official position.

Labour insiders made it clear to Sky News' political editor Beth Rigby that if frontbenchers defied the party position and voted with the SNP, they would have to stand down.

And one Labour source also told Sky News: "The order at the moment is if you’re on the frontbench and you vote for [the SNP amendment] you won’t be on the frontbench anymore."

Another party source said a number of ministers may resign in advance, adding: "Maybe [a Labour amendment] will be enough for some, but it won't be enough for a lot."

But it doesn't appear to be stopping backbenchers from offering their support to the SNP motion.

Former shadow chancellor, John McDonnell, told Sky News: "I will be voting along with several colleagues for a ceasefire and therefore for the SNP amendment if no other is called by the Speaker.

"I don't think he will call any other but the SNP's so I will be voting for that."

Sir Keir's position on a ceasefire in Gaza has followed much of the international community, including the UK and US governments.

Speaking at an event a fortnight ago where he attempted to draw a line under the mutiny in his party, the Labour leader said a ceasefire "always freezes any conflict in the state where it currently lies".

He added: "That would leave Hamas with the infrastructure and the capabilities to carry out the sort of attack we saw on 7 October.

"Attacks that are still ongoing. Hostages who should be released still held. Hamas would be emboldened and start preparing for future violence immediately."

However, a number of councillors have quit the party over his stance, and one shadow minister, Imran Hussain, also resigned from his post.

Read more:
Grassroots Tories' fury at Rishi Sunak after sacking Suella Braverman revealed in leaked WhatsApps

Earlier in the Commons, there appeared to be little shift in position from shadow foreign secretary David Lammy.

He said the current short pauses in the Israel-Hamas conflict were "clearly not enough" to help those trapped in Gaza, and pushed for a "full, comprehensive and immediate humanitarian pause in fighting".

Speaking about a possible motion on Wednesday, a Labour figure said: "We want to table something Labour MPs can vote for that is consistent with our policy while reflecting ongoing concerns on the ground.

"We would want people to vote for our amendment and vote against the SNP amendment. Why support SNP political game playing?"

But SNP sources have said Wednesday's vote would not be a one-off, and they would keep up the pressure on Sir Keir and his MPs to back a ceasefire - drawing a dividing line between the two parties.

Rate this item
(0 votes)

HOW TO LISTEN

103.5 & 105.3FM

Online

Mobile Apps

Smart Speaker